Redbubble in trouble – breach of Hells Angels IP

Hells-Angels-TM-2

The infamous Hells Angels motorcycle club has followed a more conventional form of protecting itself than one may have expected – filing a claim against online art marketplace Redbubble (http://www.redbubble.com/about) for infringing its registered trade mark/s .

Hells Angels Motorcycle Corporation currently has 10 registered trade marks in Australia over varying combinations of its winged skull logo and name (Hells Angels). These trade marks cover a range of goods and services including clothing, apparel and printed material – the same goods Redbubble was allegedly selling with Hells Angels trade marks on them.


Provided Hells Angels put forward clear evidence of infringement of their trade mark/s the court should on the face of things have a straight forward job of ruling in Hells Angels favour. Though the court shouldn’t have difficulties in coming to a decision against Redbubble, they will have a tough job weighing up a number of competing factors when determining the amount of damages to award.

On the one hand Redbubble has breached a registered trade mark and such behaviour needs to be deterred, but on the other hand there are a number relevant factors that are in Redbubble’s favour which the court would need to consider, including:

  1. Redbubble’s timely removal of the infringing goods following Hell Angels’ request;
  2. The nature of the Redbubble site being a marketplace encouraging hands on artist involvement with low contribution barriers;
  3. Hells Angels being a not for profit organisation that does not readily commercialise goods with its trade marks on it; and
  4. The gimmick style of apparel allegedly sold (e.g. HELLS ANGELS MATHS CLUB) which arguably detracts from the flagrancy of Redbubble’s alleged infringement.

Redbubble is no doubt aware of the arguments available to it with respect to limiting damages the court will award. Consequently, it is foreseeable that Redbubble will hold its ground at least in the first instance if Hells Angels come to the negotiating table with a hard line strategy.

Time could also be  on Redbubble’s side, from a commercial standpoint the continuation of this dispute will no doubt bring a great deal of welcomed free publicity to the emerging business.

It will be very interesting to see how this plays out and whether it goes the distance. If it does, the weight the court gives the various circumstances will no doubt offer an insightful and much needed guide to their current stance on trade mark infringement over the internet.

Further reading:

http://www.smh.com.au/business/retail/outlaw-motorcycle-gang-hells-angels-sues-tech-startup-for-ip-breach-20151009-gk5fmc

Back to Articles
Redchip

Recent Articles

empty hall
Major change to the Commercial Building Disclosure Program

From 1 July 2017, expansion of the CBD Program will require most sellers and lessors of office space 1,000 square metres or more to obtain a Building Energy Efficiency Certificate before the building goes on the market.

Read more
With House Model And Stack Of Coins On Desk
GST and new property sales

From 1 July 2018, purchasers of new residential premises (new homes or apartments) and subdivided residential lots will need to pay any applicable GST on the sale directly to the ATO.

Read more
aircraft Wing
Investors lose depreciation and travel deductions

From 1 July 2017, Australian Residential Property Investors will lose two long-standing tax deductions for residential properties as a result of the Federal Budget 2017.

Read more